The patterns came from this book: Paper Bag Puppets by Arden Druce. It includes many other presidents and historical figures, as well as some seasonal and fairy/traditional tale figures. All I did was run copies on regular copy paper. The kids then colored them with crayons or markers, cut them out, and glued them onto paper bags.
I also made copies of the biographical information to be glued on the back of the puppet. These are written in the first person, so it works well for a puppet show. I played patriotic music and set up the puppet stage for the kids to play with their puppets. I really wish I had gotten a picture of them doing so because it was so cute and funny! This was a super easy and fun craft–as well as being educational!